top of page

Subcontractor Or Employee? Getting The Tradie Distinction Right

Writer: Rocco Lagana
Rocco Lagana
Nov 10
7 min read

Last Updated November 2026


You've had the same worker on site for two years. He's got an ABN, he invoices you every fortnight, and nobody has ever queried it. As far as everyone on the job is concerned, he's a subcontractor.


Here's what a lot of builders miss. Not one of those three things decides whether he's a subcontractor or an employee— and there isn't a single answer to the question either. The ATO, the Fair Work Act and two South Australian schemes each ask it differently, and they can land differently on the same worker.


Most of the arrangements we end up unpicking weren't set up to dodge anything. They were set up the way the industry has always done it, years ago, and nobody has looked at them since. The short version: what you call someone, and what the paperwork says, is the one thing that doesn't matter. Here's what does, and what it costs when the answer turns out to be the wrong one.



Construction Workers

There Isn't One Test


Four separate sets of rules can apply to the same worker:


Tax and super use the ATO's test, built on the legal rights and obligations in the contract.

Workplace entitlements — wages, leave, unfair dismissal — use the Fair Work Act test, which since 26 August 2024 looks at how the relationship actually runs.

SA payroll tax, ReturnToWork SA cover and contractor reporting have their own rules again, and can pull a genuine contractor into your obligations without making them your employee.


You can pass one and fail another on the same worker.


Test One: The ATO's Test, For Tax And Super


The ATO works from seven indicators, and is explicit that none decides it alone and they aren't a checklist to total up.


Employee vs Subcontractor Test

he questions that settle it are rarely the ones people lead with.


  • Client: "He's a subcontractor. He's got an ABN and he invoices me every fortnight."

  • Us: "How much of the week does he work for you, whose tools is he using, and who decides when he finishes for the day?"

  • Client: "...most of the week. My tools. And I do, I suppose."


That's control, tools and integration — three of the seven, all pointing the same way.


Since the High Court's 2022 decisions in Personnel Contracting and Jamsek, what gets assessed is the legal rights and obligations between you and the worker, not the general impression of the relationship. That only helps you if the contract is comprehensive and in writing. Where the arrangement is oral or half-written, as it usually is in the trades, the terms get worked out from the whole arrangement, conduct included — and a handshake and a fortnightly invoice gives you nothing to point at.


The label is worth nothing either way: a clause calling someone an independent contractor doesn't turn an employee into one, or change your PAYG withholding and super obligations.


Test Two: Fair Work, And Why Your Structure Changes It


From 26 August 2024, the Fair Work Act asks whether — looking at the real substance, practical reality and true nature of the relationship — there's an employment relationship. Not just the contract: all parts of it, including how the contract is performed in practice.


Here's the part almost nobody gets right. That test only applies to constitutionally covered businesses — in practice Pty Ltd or Ltd, including a trust with a company as trustee. Trade as a sole trader or a partnership in South Australia, or through a trust with individual trustees, and you're generally a state referred business, where the older start of relationship test still applies.


Read that twice: incorporating can change which workplace test applies to the same crew doing the same work. It doesn't change the ATO's test at all. If structure is on your list anyway, run the two together — our guide to choosing a business structure covers the rest of that decision.


There's an opt-out for contractors earning above the contractor high income threshold, $190,100 from 1 July 2026, but it's the worker's call and most subcontractors are nowhere near it.


Sham contracting. Telling a worker they're a contractor when they're an employee can be sham contracting, unless you can show you reasonably believed otherwise — and "everyone does it this way" is not a reasonable belief. Maximum penalties run to $21,840 for an individual, which includes a sole trader or a partnership, and for a company, $109,200 — or $546,000 if it isn't a small business employer. Per contravention, not per audit. Those are the values at the penalty unit that took effect on 1 July 2026; the Fair Work Ombudsman's own page still shows the older, lower figures.


The Super Trap That Catches Careful Businesses


You can get the classification right and still owe super.


Where a contract is mainly for a person's labour — the ATO's measure is more than half the dollar value — super is payable on the labour component even though the worker has an ABN and invoices you. Three conditions have to line up: the contract is mainly for labour, you're paying for their personal labour rather than a specified result, and they have to do the work themselves. It doesn't apply where your contract is with a company, trust or partnership.


So the labourer who turns up with his own hand tools, gets paid by the day and can't send someone else in his place? Super is almost certainly payable, whatever the paperwork calls him. The concreter who quotes a fixed price for a slab, brings a crew and a truck, and wears the cost if he gets it wrong? Almost certainly not.


Two practical details. Split labour from materials in the quote — if the contract doesn't, you have to apportion on reasonable market value and keep the working. And Payday Super changed the deadline: for pay from 1 July 2026, super has to reach the fund within 7 business days of each payday, at 12%. An invoice caught by the labour test is caught by that timing too — and since the ATO hasn't said what the payday is for an invoice, treat the date you pay it as the trigger and ask us if the timing is tight.


Three Layers That Catch Genuine Contractors


None of these reclassifies anyone. They sit on top.


SA payroll tax. "Relevant contract" provisions deem contractor payments to be wages unless one of a handful of exemptions applies. The whole payment counts, less GST — a deduction for materials and equipment is only available for some kinds of contractor, at set percentages. Payroll tax starts once Australia-wide wages pass $1.5 million a year, and payments to subcontractors count towards that threshold (our SA payroll tax guide covers it).


ReturnToWork SA. Building work is a prescribed class under the SA return to work scheme — wall and floor tiling excluded — so a self-employed contractor doing building work for you can be a deemed worker — meaning you may be their employer for workers compensation and paying premiums on them. Check before the injury, not after.


TPAR. If at least 50% of your income or activity is building and construction services this year, or at least 50% of your income was last year, you lodge a Taxable payments annual report listing what you paid each contractor, due 28 August. The ATO data-matches it against what the subcontractor declared.


What It Costs To Get It Wrong


Reclassification is backdated: the PAYG withholding you should have withheld plus a penalty, and Fair Work exposure for unpaid award entitlements and leave on top of the sham contracting penalties above.


The super guarantee charge is the big one. For pay from 1 July 2026 the ATO assesses it per payday: the unpaid super, notional earnings compounding daily, an administrative uplift starting at 60%, and a choice loading. The uplift drops by 20 percentage points if you've had no ATO-initiated assessment in two years, and by up to 40 points for a voluntary disclosure lodged before assessment — disclose within 30 days with a clean history and it reaches nil. That's the single biggest lever available, and it only exists before the ATO finds it first.


Older periods are worse. Super guarantee shortfalls aren't subject to the usual amendment time limits, and quarters up to 30 June 2026 run on the old rules: shortfall, nominal interest, an administration fee and a penalty of up to 200% of the charge. That older charge isn't deductible either, where the post-July 2026 one is once you've paid it.


What To Do About It


  1. Pick your three most arguable arrangements — the three you'd least like to defend.

  2. Run each against the seven indicators, as the job actually runs. Then run the super labour test separately, because it can land differently.

  3. Check which Fair Work test applies to you — Pty Ltd, or sole trader and partnership.

  4. Get the arrangement in writing, describing the job as it's really done. A contract that doesn't match the site is worse than useless.

  5. If something's wrong, move before the ATO does.


Check each new worker before they start, too. The same person can be a contractor on one job and an employee on the next..





General information only – speak to your accountant about your situation. This article covers general Australian tax, superannuation and workplace concepts and is current as at November 2026. Worker classification depends on the specific facts of each arrangement, penalties and thresholds change, and workplace relations questions can require legal advice. Nothing here is a determination about any particular worker.




Frequently Asked Questions


No, and it's the ATO's number one myth. An ABN says something about how that person is registered for tax. It says nothing about your working arrangement with them.

Sometimes. If the contract is mainly for their own labour and they can't delegate the work, super is payable on the labour component despite the ABN and the invoice. If your contract is with a company, trust or partnership, or you're genuinely paying for a result, it generally isn't.

Yes. The tests are different and can give different answers on the same worker. That's not a loophole, it's the current state of the law — and it's why a single "contractor or not" verdict is usually too simple.

Work out the exposure before you do anything else, then look at voluntary disclosure. Fixing it on your own terms is substantially cheaper than being found, and the uplift reduction only exists beforehand.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page