When Should A Sole Trader Become A Company? The Trigger Points

Last Updated November 2026
One person tells you that once you're making $100,000 you should be in a company. Someone else says wait until you're turning over half a million. Your last accountant mentioned it in passing and you never followed it up.
None of that advice knows what you're actually doing with the money, which is the only thing that decides it.
Becoming a company isn't a reward for hitting a number. It's a tool that solves specific problems. Here's how to tell whether you've got one of those problems yet.

The Short Answer: It's Not A Profit Figure
The "$100,000 rule" is the most repeated piece of structure advice in the country, and it's wrong often enough to be dangerous.
The logic behind it is that a company pays 25% while you're paying 37c in the dollar at the top of your income, so the company must be cheaper. That's true of the money you leave in the company. It is not true of the money you take out to live on.
A dollar you pull out of a company to pay your mortgage ends up taxed at your marginal rate, the same as it would have been as a sole trader. The company tax paid on it comes back to you as a franking credit, and you top up the difference. The structure didn't save you anything on that dollar. It just moved when you paid.
So the question isn't "how much do I make?". It's "how much do I leave behind?".
Trigger One: You're Consistently Leaving Profit In The Business
This is the real tax trigger. If you're earning more than you need to live on, and the surplus is sitting in the business funding stock, tools, vehicles or a buffer, a company lets that surplus sit there taxed at 25% instead of your marginal rate.
Here's what that looks like on $160,000 of profit, where you need $110,000 to live on and the other $50,000 stays in the business.

About $4,250 better off. Worth doing?
Maybe — but read the next bit before you decide, because that number is not what it looks like.
That $4,250 is a deferral, not a discount. The $50,000 is still sitting in the company with $12,500 of tax paid on it. The day you pay it out to yourself as a dividend, you pay top-up tax at your marginal rate. If you're still on the same income then, the top-up is around $7,000 — and $12,500 plus $7,000 is exactly what you'd have paid as a sole trader.
The saving is real only if one of these is true:
The money stays in the business and does something. It buys the vehicle, funds the stock, carries you through a quiet quarter. You were never going to take it out.
You take it out in a year when your income is lower. A year off, a slow year, a year you're building something else.
If neither is true, you've bought yourself a deferral and an annual compliance bill. Some people want the deferral. Just know that's what you're buying.
Trigger Two: What You'd Lose If Something Went Wrong
As a sole trader, there's no line between you and the business. A claim that exceeds your insurance reaches whatever you own.
That's an abstract risk right up until it isn't, and it tends to grow quietly: bigger jobs, higher contract values, employees doing work in your name, equipment on site, a premises with a lease on it.
The honest framing is that a company is a layer, not a shield. Directors still carry personal duties, lenders routinely ask for personal guarantees, and a guarantee you've signed goes straight through the company. What it does change is the default position, and on bigger work that's worth having.
If the answer to "what's the worst job on my books and what happens if it goes badly?" has got noticeably worse in the last two years, that's a trigger.
Trigger Three: Someone Else Is Asking For It
This one decides it more often than tax does.
Head contractors, government panels, larger clients and some insurers will only engage a company. You find out when you're filling in the prequalification form, which is usually two weeks before the tender closes and far too late to set one up cleanly.
If the work you're chasing next year looks different from the work you're doing this year, check the paperwork requirements before you need them.
Trigger Four: You're Bringing Someone In, Or Planning To Get Out
A sole trader structure has no way to let someone else in. There's nothing to divide.
If you're thinking about a business partner, an equity-holding key employee, or selling the business in the next few years, a company gives you something to transfer. Sorting that out before anyone's money is on the table is far cheaper than restructuring around it afterwards — and restructuring later can trigger tax on the way through.
Our post on the best business structure for a startup covers the options side of this, and company or trust goes through choosing between the two.
Three Reasons To Wait
Your income is personal services income. If what you sell is essentially your own skill and labour, and you don't satisfy the relevant tests, the personal services income rules can attribute the income back to you personally regardless of the company. The structure changes, the tax doesn't. This catches contractors, consultants and anyone working mainly through one client, and it's worth checking before you incorporate rather than after.
You're making losses. A sole trader can sometimes offset a business loss against other income — wages from a job, for instance — if the non-commercial loss rules are met. A company's losses are trapped in the company until it makes a profit, subject to its own tests. If you're in the investment phase and have other income, a company may be the wrong structure right now.
The money doesn't justify the admin. A company means ASIC's annual review fee — $342 at the moment — plus a separate tax return, financial statements, a separate bank account, director obligations and more bookkeeping. Call it a four-figure sum a year all up, before anyone's saved a dollar in tax. On a $4,250 deferral, a decent chunk of the benefit goes straight back out.
And one trap worth knowing about in advance: once you're a company, the money in the business account isn't yours to take at will. Drawing it out the wrong way can be treated as a deemed dividend and taxed, which is what Division 7A is about. How you pay yourself becomes a decision rather than a habit — our post on how much you should pay yourself is a good place to start on that.
So What Actually Decides It
Ask yourself these four questions:
How much profit am I leaving in the business each year, honestly? Not how much I make. How much I don't spend.
What's my exposure, and has it grown?
Is anyone asking me for a company, or about to?
Is anyone else going to own part of this, now or later?
A yes to one of the last three is usually enough on its own. Trigger one alone is a numbers question, and it's worth running the numbers on your actual position before you move — including what the change itself costs, which isn't nothing.
Not Sure Which Side Of The Line You're On?
The honest answer for a lot of sole traders is "not yet, and here's what would change that". That's a twenty-minute conversation, not a project. If you're starting out, or you think this year might be the year, our Entrepreneur Starter Pack covers the structure decision and the set-up in one fixed-fee package
General information only – speak to your accountant about your situation. Current as at November 2026 and based on 2026-27 rates. The worked example is illustrative and assumes the company qualifies for the 25% company tax rate; it ignores superannuation and any other income you have. Your own position depends on your income, your other circumstances and the rules that apply to you. Tax rates, thresholds, offsets and government fees change.
Frequently Asked Questions
At what income should a sole trader become a company?
There isn't a threshold. The common "$100,000" rule of thumb misses the point, because the company rate only helps on profit you leave in the business. Profit you draw out to live on is taxed at your marginal rate either way. The better question is how much you consistently leave behind.
Does a company actually save tax?
Only on retained profit, and even then it's often a deferral rather than a saving. Profit taxed in the company at 25% carries a franking credit, and when it's paid out to you as a dividend you top up to your marginal rate. The benefit is real where the money stays in the business or comes out in a lower-income year.
What does it cost to run a company?
ASIC's annual review fee is $342 at present, and on top of that you have a separate tax return and financial statements, a separate bank account, and more bookkeeping. Budget for a four-figure annual cost before any tax benefit.
Will a company protect my personal assets?
It changes the default position, but it isn't absolute. Directors have personal duties, lenders commonly require personal guarantees, and a guarantee you sign reaches you directly. Treat it as one layer of protection alongside proper insurance, not a replacement for it.
Should I become a company if my income is personal services income?
Usually it won't change the tax outcome. Where the personal services income rules apply, the income can be attributed back to you personally regardless of the structure. This is worth checking before you set a company up.
Can I change back if it doesn't suit me?
You can, but unwinding is generally harder and more expensive than setting up, and moving assets between structures can trigger tax. That's the argument for getting advice on the timing rather than incorporating because it feels like the next step.




Comments